Reflections

Gently Disagree

“Cheer up, Sarah.”

I don’t speak up for myself as often as I should. Complaints practically have to rip themselves out of me; I will bear it and bear it and wear myself out, one scrap at a time, before I find the courage to admit out loud that something is wrong.

That’s a weakness, by the way, not a strength. In theory, I value direct communication over silence and resentment. But I struggle to vocalize my needs sometimes, especially when the person I know I need to talk to hasn’t had a history of hearing me well. Sooner or later, it’s easier to shut down and give up, to stop fighting so hard against the relentless current and just take it if you so obviously must.

And yet, deeper down, I can’t ever quite forget that I was born a freedom fighter, and it burns me bitterly to silence the truth. When everyone around me keeps their mouths shut against all the frustrations that they’ve shared with me in private, eventually I hit a point of breaking past my hesitations and not caring what people think anymore. I say it, for me and for them, even if no one else will. And once again, I’m the one who ends up looking grumpy when I know I’m just the only one who’s willing to say what half of everyone is thinking.

I’d like to pretend that my courage extends to not caring how other people respond afterwards. An invalidating, “Cheer up, Sarah,” tossed my way rolls right off my back like so much dust; I know who I am and I know what’s true, and I am above the opinions of mere mortals. But in the authorized autobiography, being reminded that my pain can be so easily dismissed, my image reduced to that of a petulant child by people who have no idea and do not care to ask what obstacles I’ve been up against for the last six months sends me to hide in a locked room by myself and cry like a kid. You can know you shouldn’t care—that you won’t care once you’re a few more miles down the road—and still have to cry it out of your system sometimes.

Because at the end of the day, I prefer to contribute to a culture that can handle tough conversations, where you don’t have to be happy and you’re allowed to disagree. I suffocate in groups that demand smiles and consensus, while I relax when I can tell that saying “no” and pushing back are a regular part of the rhythm of the room. So you don’t have to like it, but I’m going to stay honest, if only to keep my own integrity intact. I refuse to ever smother my own soul just to please those who value the appearance of pleasantries over the actual, tangible wellness of every individual involved. I’ve fought too hard out of too many coffins to roll over and play dead for anyone else’s shallow system.

Speak up, friend, when it’s important and you need to. I don’t mean you should cry over spilled milk; I’m not talking about immature tantrums or an imagined victim complex. Choose your battles, but then fight them well. Speak always with kindness and respect. Articulate what you mean clearly, and avoid raising your voice if you possibly can. But speak, you truth-teller, speak, always speak, and gently disagree with anyone who tells you that you haven’t yet earned your voice. No one can muzzle you, though many might try. Let yourself be shamed and called names, and check your conscience and your God to know you’re not missing the mark or calling it wrong, but then do your best and never let your needs be bulldozed by someone who knows better.

Live by the truth, no matter what it costs you.

Reflections

Arrows in My Fists

The other women are cooing with inspiration tonight, thankful and blessed in their pastel smiles, but I’m a whirling wind of anger that won’t settle. I want it to settle: it’s hot in my ribcage, a sizzling itch, but I am stuck with it. This one isn’t worth it, I tell myself. Didn’t I tell my students to choose their battles? But it’s not the issue at hand that hurts so much; it’s the buildup. How many slaps to the face can you take before you’re no longer laughing?

I don’t know where to stand anymore. In the rearview mirror, I see a girl who always chose forgiveness and kindness and love. She’s still the person I want to be, but I can’t reach her; some days, it feels like she’s long dead and decayed into a zombie whose best smile comes out as a snarl. But when I flex the mirror a different direction, that girl looks a lot less glamorous. She was incompetent, codependent, often flinching away from hard truths. She didn’t know how to stand up for herself. She could be sickeningly weak.

And maybe that’s what I push back against now. I don’t think it’s cute to airbrush on blithe little quotes about a love that you don’t understand when in reality you’re choosing compliance over conviction because you’re desperate for approval. I don’t think it’s kind or sweet to go along with a lie. I cannot respect cowardice or ego disguised as service of the public good; I’m uninterested in meaningless repetitions of pop catchphrases. Nothing is remotely inspirational unless it is first bone-deep true and transparent to its core, and that often involves a good deal of grit. As my friend Melody once said, “I like my friends a little grumpy.” If you cannot name and rebuke the darkness, then you have no right to pretend you know a thing about light.

Tonight, I am angry, but I don’t want this to be my permanent state. I mull over forgiveness and how much harder it sounds these days. All I can cling to is that its power comes from its being a choice; I can look you in the eye, recognize what you are doing as wrong—and yes, I can say so—and then, I have the right to choose to forgive you, knowing full well that you don’t deserve it. There is power in that, I think. This isn’t roll-over-dead submission or shrinking away like the fake forgiveness they try to string around a whimsy little heart-shaped necklace, a denial of frustration or of pain. This means recognizing the truth for what it is and then refusing to let others’ sins and abuses dictate my emotions or my heart before the Lord. It is, in its own way, a form of resistance: I may speak up when it’s right, and I may hold out when it’s important, but you may not hold my spirit captive or take my heart away from me.

Ain’t gonna happen. I’m not stooping to your level; I won’t let the bitterness drown out mercy and justice. I release you to Jesus and pray goodness over your life, though my emotions may not yet be on the same page as my prayers. I have to keep refusing hatred as stubbornly as I refuse to be controlled.

It’s wrong it’s wrong it’s wrong it’s wrong. But I don’t need to be the one to fix it, to fix you. The God of vengeance, the God of grace will always take up my case, and He’ll bring down the gavel exactly where it needs to land at the cataclysmic end of time. In the meantime, I know the truth and I hold the truth and I speak the truth and do not flinch away from it, even if it makes me less popular and less understood than the softer women with their too-white lace. I hold the truth and I speak the truth, and I set you free and wish you grace, both at the same time.

Goodness and grace to wear down your anger until only compassion remains.
Goodness and grace to bless you with wellness in body and soul.
Goodness and grace to grow you up.
Goodness and grace where you least expect it and deserve it even less.

I can’t say tonight if I’ll end up pushing back or not, because I don’t know how far you’re going to try to invade. I don’t know where my prayers will lead me, what my Lord will say, how much land I can surrender or which borders I simply must defend. But Jesus, help me speak up for them if I must with goodness and grace, with every person’s dignity and infinite value ever present before me. “Who am I to touch the Lord’s anointed?” the psalmist asked, respectful of his own would-be murderer.

I’m bloodier and uglier than the other women, but arrows in my fists and scars on my hands, I’m setting you free instead of striking out for revenge. You won’t love me for it; no one will sing my praises. I will simply watch you skitter away until the thin moon takes your place, and I will watch it in the stillness, and somewhere you can’t reach me I will hear the voice of God.

Reflections

Resistance is a hard-won art

Last night, I dreamed that I was with a group of people who were practicing saying the word no together. That’s all: we just repeated the word, slowly at first and then with confidence, until the sound of no was normal and not so scary anymore.

I knew in my dream that we didn’t have to practice the word yes because that word would come to us easily, automatically. Agreement and acceptance, going along with the crowd, being liked, being compliant—no one needs to practice easy street. We would find a yes for every fitting situation without even having to search for it, without even having to think.

But some moments would demand a much braver no, and no demands practice, intentionality, resolve. You cannot say no in front of a smoking gun without strength of character to carry you through. We practiced because we knew the moment would come, and when it came, we would have already made the decision to choose conviction over comfort, always. We wouldn’t have to bear the weight of a dizzying decision in the heat of the emotional moment, because we had done the hard work of choosing well in advance: just no. No. No. No.


this is my never-ending no
to all coercion and control

Poetry

Out of Control

Be careful, little heart, what you learn,

because once you know
that your soul is your own,
you can never forget—

and they will hate you for that.